Old vs New Tax Regime: A Comprehensive Guide for FY 2023-24


The Finance Budget of 2020 brought about a significant change in the Indian tax landscape with the introduction of the New Tax Regime. This new tax regime aimed to attract taxpayers with its concessional tax rates. However, it came with a catch – taxpayers choosing the new regime would have to forgo many of the exemptions, deductions, and allowances they were accustomed to under the Old Tax Regime. In this article, we’ll explore the fundamental differences between the Old vs New Tax Regime to help you make an informed choice for your financial planning.

Key Differences between Old vs New Tax Regime:

  1. House Rent Allowance (HRA) Sec. 10(13A):
    • Old Regime: Allows HRA deduction.
    • New Regime: Does not allow HRA deduction.
  2. Standard Deduction Sec. 16(ia):
    • Old Regime: Allows standard deduction.
    • New Regime: Allows standard deduction.
  3. Interest on Self-Occupied Home Loan Sec. 24(b):
    • Old Regime: Allows interest on self-occupied home loan deduction.
    • New Regime: Does not allow interest on self-occupied home loan deduction.
  4. Sec 80C Deductions (e.g., PPF, LIC, Tax Saving Mutual Funds):
    • Old Regime: Allows Sec 80C deductions.
    • New Regime: Does not allow Sec 80C deductions.
  5. Medical Health Insurance Sec. 80D:
    • Old Regime: Allows medical health insurance deduction.
    • New Regime: Does not allow medical health insurance deduction.
  6. National Pension Scheme (NPS) 80CCD(1B):
    • Old Regime: Allows NPS deduction.
    • New Regime: Does not allow NPS deduction.
  7. Contribution To Pension Scheme By Employer 80CCD(2):
    • Old Regime: Allows employer’s contribution to NPS deduction.
    • New Regime: Allows employer’s contribution to NPS deduction.
  8. Interest on Education Loan Sec. 80E:
    • Old Regime: Allows interest on education loan deduction.
    • New Regime: Does not allow interest on education loan deduction.

In summary, the New Tax Regime (F.Y. 2023-24 onwards) offers only two deductions:

  1. Standard deduction of Rs. 50,000 (for salary income).
  2. Deduction under Section 80CCD(2) for the employer’s contribution to the NPS fund.

Choosing Between Old and New Regimes:

Your choice between the old and new tax regimes depends on your financial situation. Here’s a general guideline:

  • Old Regime: If you have numerous deductions and exemptions available and you can maximize your tax savings with these, the old regime may be more beneficial for you. It’s especially advantageous if you have significant investments under Section 80C or if you are repaying an Education Loan, among other deductions.
  • New Regime: If you prefer lower tax rates and a simpler tax structure, the new regime might be a better choice, especially if your financial situation is relatively straightforward and you don’t have many deductions or exemptions to claim.

New Tax Regime as the Default Option: Starting from the Financial Year 2023-24, the new tax regime becomes the default option for salaried employees. This means that your employer will deduct tax based on the new regime unless you specify your preference for the old regime. To choose the old regime, you must file Form 10-IEA when filing your income tax return.

Conclusion: Understanding the differences between the old vs new tax regime is crucial for making an informed decision that aligns with your financial goals. Whether you opt for the old regime with its deductions and exemptions or the new regime for lower tax rates, your choice should match your unique financial situation and preferences. Make sure to consult with a tax professional if you’re uncertain about which regime is the right choice for you. Your tax planning strategy should ultimately serve your financial well-being while ensuring compliance with tax regulations.

For more information and expert assistance, kindly visit www.apkireturn.com. Our team of tax professionals will assist you in selecting the best tax regime for you.



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *