Set Off & Carry Forward of Losses: Tax Rules & Benefits Explained

Introduction

Effectively managing losses through taxation can significantly impact financial outcomes for individuals and businesses. The concepts of ‘set off’ and ‘carry forward’ allow taxpayers to reduce their tax liability by adjusting losses against current or future income. While ‘set off’ enables balancing losses against income within the same year, ‘carry forward’ helps defer unadjusted losses to future years. These provisions are powerful tools for optimizing tax planning, enhancing cash flow, and ensuring financial stability. This blog simplifies these concepts, highlighting their rules, applications, and importance in strategic tax management.

Definitions:

Set Off of Losses: It refers to the process where taxpayers can offset losses incurred from one source of income against profits from another source within the same head of income or different heads, within the same financial year. This helps in reducing the taxable income for that year, thereby decreasing the overall tax liability.

Carry Forward of Losses: It is a provision that allows taxpayers to carry forward their unadjusted losses to subsequent years. These losses can then be set off against future income, helping to reduce taxable income in those future years. There are specific rules regarding how long different types of losses can be carried forward and against what types of future income they can be set off.

Set Off of Losses

Explanation of Set Off: Set off is a vital tool in tax planning, allowing for the balancing of losses against gains, thus optimizing the tax outlay. The process is subject to strict rules and conditions to ensure it is applied correctly and fairly.

Types of Set Off:

• Inter-source Set Off: This occurs within the same head of income, such as setting off a loss from one rental property against profits from another within the ‘Income from House Property’ category.
• Inter-head Set Off: This broader application allows losses from one head of income, like business losses, to be set off against another, such as salary income. However, certain restrictions apply, particularly with speculative businesses and capital gains

Carry Forward of Losses

Explanation of Carrying Forward: When losses cannot be fully set off in the fiscal year they are incurred, the carry forward provision allows these losses to be used in subsequent years. This ensures that businesses and individuals can get eventual tax relief, aiding in long-term financial planning.

Types of Losses and Periods:

• Different types of losses have specific carry forward rules. For instance, capital losses can be carried forward for eight years, but must still only be set off against capital gains.
• Business losses (other than speculative losses) can also be carried forward for eight years and may be set off against any business income.

Restrictions and Prohibitions on Set Off and Carry Forward of Losses

When managing taxes through the set off and carry forward of losses, it is crucial to understand the specific restrictions and prohibitions that govern these processes. These limitations are designed to prevent misuse of the tax relief provisions and ensure that the benefits are availed in the intended manner.

Restrictions on Set Off of Losses

• Speculative Business Losses: These can only be set off against income from speculative businesses. They cannot be adjusted against non-speculative business incomes or any other head of income, ensuring that high-risk business activities don’t unduly benefit from broader income sources.
• Capital Losses: Short-term capital losses can be set off against both short-term and long-term capital gains. However, long-term capital losses are restricted to being set off only against long-term capital gains. This restriction helps maintain the integrity of tax on long-term investments.
• Loss under the Head ‘House Property’: While losses under this head can be set off against other income, such set off is capped at ₹2 lakh per annum under New Regime, which limits the tax relief from high-value property losses in any single year.
• Non-allowable Expenses: Losses arising from expenses that are expressly disallowed under the tax laws, such as personal expenses or penalties, cannot be set off against taxable income.

Restrictions On Carry Forward of Losses

• Time Limit: Most losses, except for unabsorbed depreciation and certain corporate losses under specific provisions, can be carried forward only for a maximum of eight years. After this period, they lapse and cannot be used to reduce tax liability.
• Filing Deadlines: Losses can be carried forward only if the taxpayer has filed the income tax return within the prescribed due dates i.e. time limit u/s 139 (1) of the Income tax Act, 1961. Late filing can lead to forfeiture of the carry forward benefit for that year.
• Ownership Continuity: In the case of business losses, there must be continuity of business ownership from the year in which the loss was incurred to the year of set off to qualify for carry forward benefits. This is particularly relevant for companies where a change in ownership can disqualify the loss carry forward.

Prohibitions

• Salary Income: No losses can be set off against salary income. This is to prevent salaried individuals from using business or speculative losses to reduce their taxable salary.
• Losses from Illegal Activities: Losses incurred from activities that are illegal or not permitted by law cannot be used to offset income from legal sources, maintaining the ethical standards of tax filing.

Practical Example

Mr. Sharma is a software developer who also invests in the stock market. During the financial year, he incurred a loss of ₹1,50,000 from by selling short-term stocks. Additionally, he owns two rental properties, one of which suffered a loss of ₹3,00,000 due to high maintenance costs and vacancy periods, while the other earned a rental income of ₹4,00,000.

Application Of Set Off & Carry Forward of Rules

1. Inter-source Adjustment within the Same Head (House Property):

1. • Loss from Property A: ₹3,00,000
   • Income from Property B: ₹4,00,000
   • Mr. Sharma can set off the loss from Property A against the income from Property B, effectively reducing his taxable income from house property to ₹1,00,000.

2. Carrying Forward Excess Loss:

1. • The net income from house property after set off is ₹1,00,000, but he still has an unadjusted loss of ₹2,00,000.
   • Since the set off limit under the house property head is capped at ₹2 lakh, he cannot use the remaining ₹2,00,000 to reduce other income types within the same year.
   • This ₹2,00,000 can be carried forward for up to eight years, but can only be set off against future house property income.

3. Set Off of Capital Losses:

1. • Short-term Capital Loss: ₹1,50,000
   • Mr. Sharma can use this ₹1,50,000 loss to offset any short-term or long-term capital gains he might have during the same financial year. If he has no other capital gains, this loss can be carried forward to subsequent years (up to eight years) and set off against future capital gains.

• Timely Filing Requirement: Mr. Sharma must file his income tax return on time to carry forward the unadjusted house property loss and the short-term capital loss.
• Ownership Continuity: For the carry forward of business losses (not applicable in this scenario but important in general), he would need to maintain ownership of the business or assets through the carry forward period.

This example illustrates how set off and carry forward rules function in practical scenarios, helping taxpayers like Mr. Sharma to manage their tax liabilities more effectively while complying with the applicable tax laws.

FAQs

1. Can I set off my house property loss against my salary income?

1. • No, losses from house property can only be set off against other house property income or carried forward to be set off against future house property income, subject to the limit of ₹2 lakh per annum.

2. What happens to my capital loss if I have no capital gains in the same year?

1. • If you incur capital losses and have no capital gains in the same year, you can carry forward these losses for up to eight years. These carried forward losses can only be set off against future capital gains.

3. Are there any types of business losses that cannot be carried forward?

1. • Speculative losses have specific rules. While non-speculative business losses can be carried forward and set off against any head of income except salary, speculative business losses can only be carried forward for four years and must be set off only against speculative income.

4. Can I carry forward losses if I miss the tax return filing deadline?

1. • Losses cannot be carried forward if the tax return is not filed within the prescribed deadline. Filing the return on time is crucial to avail of the carry forward benefit.

5. Is there a restriction on the carry forward of losses in case of ownership change in a business?

1. • Yes, for corporate entities, if there is a substantial change in the ownership of a company (more than 51%), and the company is not a startup, carried forward losses may not be allowed unless the change is under a government-approved scheme of amalgamation or demerger.

6. How does carry forward of losses work in the case of amalgamation or demerger?

1. • In cases of amalgamation or demerger, losses of the amalgamating or demerged company can be carried forward to the amalgamated or resulting company, subject to certain conditions being fulfilled, such as approval by the jurisdictional tax authority.

7. Are there any losses that cannot be set off or carried forward at all?

1. • Yes, losses from illegal activities or losses that arise from disallowed expenses (like personal expenses recorded as business expenses) cannot be set off or carried forward.

8. Can a non-resident Indian carry forward and set off losses?

1. • Non-resident Indians can carry forward and set off losses under the same rules as residents, but they must ensure that the losses are connected to income that is taxable in India.
2. Can losses from the sale of a residential property be set off against dividends or interest income?
   • No, losses from the sale of a residential property, categorized as capital losses, can only be set off against capital gains. If there are no capital gains in the same year, these losses can be carried forward and set off against future capital gains for up to eight years. They cannot be set off against other types of income such as dividends or interest, which are categorized under ‘Income from Other Sources’.
3. If I have both short-term and long-term capital losses, how should I prioritize their set off?
   • Short-term capital losses should first be set off against any short-term capital gains in the same year. If any of these losses remain unadjusted, they can then be used to offset any long-term capital gains. Conversely, long-term capital losses can only be set off against long-term capital gains. Prioritizing the use of short-term losses first maximizes the potential tax savings, as short-term gains are typically taxed at a higher rate than long-term gains.

For expert guidance, contact ApkiReturn at +91 766 515 6000 or email us at info@apkireturn.com. Visit Apkireturn.